Coalition crisis over minister’s ‘disparaging’ attack on gardaí

Coalition crisis over minister’s ‘disparaging’ attack on gardaí

Finian McGrath
Finian McGrath

Cabinet minister Finian McGrath’s career is hanging in the balance after he sparked outrage over his claim that gardaí had become politicised.

Senior Fine Gael ministers were furious with Mr McGrath’s accusation that gardaí were carrying out unnecessary breathalyser check-points because they opposed controversial new drink-driving laws.

Even after he retracted the remarks, made in an interview with the ‘Sunday Independent’, Cabinet ministers were insisting the Independent Alliance minister should not “expect everyone to forget” his comments.

One senior minister said the Disabilities Minister’s comments “should not be tolerated” by the Government.

“You can’t hold such appalling and ridiculous and insulting views on Saturday afternoon and then just change your mind on Sunday afternoon,” the minister said.

Association of Garda Sergeants and Inspectors (AGSI) chief John Jacob said the “disparaging” remarks had effectively placed gardaí enforcing the law in a “no-win situation” that left them “damned if we do and damned if we don’t”.

An Garda Síochána refused to comment directly on Mr McGrath’s remarks but insisted it was a “non-­political organisation” whose function is to keep people safe.

Mr McGrath was publicly reprimanded by Justice Minister Charlie Flanagan, who branded the comments “bizarre” and “dangerous”.

Transport Minister and fellow Independent Shane Ross was silent.

Mr McGrath was last night forced into an embarrassing climbdown after he came under massive pressure from Fine Gael and his Independent Alliance colleagues saying he was “wrong”.

He had claimed in a ‘Sunday Independent’ interview that gardaí’s implementation of the drink-driving crackdown, introduced by his Independent Alliance TD and Transport Minister Shane Ross, has been “over the top”.


#bb-iawr-inarticle- { clear: both; margin: 0 0 15px; }

Mr McGrath also called on Garda Commissioner Drew Harris to “de-politicise” the force.

He said gardaí should always be “non-political” but claimed they are now blaming Mr Ross for new drink-driving laws when they are stopping motorists at checkpoints.

“That is being said at checkpoints. That’s not good enough. That would not be tolerated in any other profession,” he said.

It prompted Mr Flanagan to label his comments as “unwise, even dangerous”.

Junior Fine Gael minister Patrick O’Donovan demanded that Mr McGrath withdraw his comments.

Mr McGrath initially stood over the remarks but later did a massive U-turn, it is understood after coming under pressure from the Independent Alliance.

He maintained: “Nobody is more supportive of the work An Garda Síochána does – often in tough circumstances – than I am.”

He said his comments were “prompted by concerns raised with me over the past number of weeks”.

But he acknowledged the concerns and that his claim of political policing in the enforcement of drink-driving regulations was “wrong”, saying: “I am happy to withdraw my comments.”

However, there is fury in Fine Gael over what one source branded “a misguided attempt to gain a bit of publicity for himself that has backfired spectacularly”.

There has also been criticism from Fianna Fáil with justice spokesman Jim O’Callaghan saying it was “extraordinary for a Government minister to state that he believes gardaí are involved in a political campaign to damage certain members of the Government”.

He said it this was true it would constitute a “serious threat to our democracy”.

The AGSI’s general secretary John Jacob said he was happy Mr McGrath had withdrawn his “disparaging remarks” but said he couldn’t understand how the minister would ever consider gardaí to be politicised.

“We’re tasked with enforcing the law impartially and we do that on a daily basis… we’re damned if we do and damned if we don’t it appears.

“If we don’t enforce the legislation and there’s an accident we’ll be asked why we weren’t more proactive,” he said.

“When we are proactive we’re told we’re over-active. It’s a no-win situation”.

He said gardaí would be disappointed that a minister would make such remarks.

Irish Independent

Comment here